The “Fugeta” pilgrim’s notes from the winter of 1919-1920 are among the most reliable. A note within the notes states that “All notes on these talks were taken in Persian by Dr. Lotfullah.” Another note on page 57 says that, with the exception of the men’s meeting on January 8, the notes were taken verbatim at table. The two-page extract regarding the question of organising the Bahai community below includes a section marked in the notes as “Dictated.” This presumably refers to Abdu’l-Baha ensuring that Dr. Lotfullah could record that section word-for-word. The interpreter at this meeting, on January 2, was probably Shoghi Effendi, since on December 29, 1919, Shoghi Effendi is reported to be the interpreter when Abdu’l-Baha met the same group of western pilgrims. I think he was also the translator of the Persian notes, as I will explain later. If these notes are translated from Dr. Lotfullah’s Persian notes — which seems likely — the authority of the text would be comparable to Some Answered Questions. Read the rest of this entry »
Archive for the ‘Community’ Category
Abdu’l-Baha speaks: “Fugeta” notes on the House of Justice and flexibility
Posted by Sen on April 13, 2023
Posted in Aqdas and Law, Church and State, Community | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai, Bahai Faith, Church and State, House of Justice, pilgrim's notes, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, Will and Testament, بهایی, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی, عبدالبهاء | 4 Comments »
Shoghi Effendi on the principle of majority decision-making
Posted by Sen on July 11, 2020
What follows is my translation of Abdu-dhalil Zarqaani’s summary of a talk given by Shoghi Effendi in 1927, in response to a question coming, apparently, from the local Spiritual Assembly of Istanbul. The details of the question are not included. Zarqani’s summary is published in a collection of Shoghi Effendi’s letters, Tawquiaat-e Mubaarakeh 1922-1948 (p. 33), which has led some authors to cite parts of it as coming from a letter written by or on behalf of Shoghi Effendi. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, source criticism, Translations | Tagged: Bahai Administrative Order, Bahai elections, Community, democracy, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 7 Comments »
Signed by Five
Posted by Sen on October 6, 2019
As I have often pointed out, it’s important to distinguish between the letters written by the Guardian and those written on his behalf. It is also important to distinguish between letters from the Universal House of Justice and those from the Secretariat or another body at the Bahai World Centre. Knowing which is which requires some checking and perhaps a direct enquiry, because many publications and databases quote from letters issued by the Secretariat, saying that they are quoting the House of Justice. Moreover letters from the Secretariat quite often cite memoranda from the Research Department, so that these too come to be cited as ‘from The House of Justice’ or on behalf of the House of Justice. This is a muddle: some clarity is needed.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: House of Justice, Sen McGlinn, Universal House of Justice, بهایی, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 11 Comments »
In search of spiritual democracy
Posted by Sen on September 14, 2018
In the 30’s and 40’s, Shoghi Effendi was encouraging the Bahais to establish the various organs of the Bahai Administrative Order, while some Bahais, notably in the Bahai community in North America, were resisting. They put forward an alternative vision, in which Baha’u’llah’s “Houses of Justice” were thought to refer to democratic governments, and the Bahai community was inclusive and had no permanent organization at all. Three ‘quotes’ from Abdu’l-Baha were central to this vision of what a Bahai community could be: “you cannot organize the Bahai Movement, the Bahai Movement is the spirit of the age” “There are no officers in this Cause” and “The foundation of this Cause is pure spiritual democracy.”
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Defence of the Faith, Polemics, source criticism, Theology | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai, Bahai Faith, Bahai lore, Howard MacNutt, Mirza Ahmad Sohrab, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 32 Comments »
Houses of Worship in all the lands
Posted by Sen on September 1, 2018
[Revised July 2019]
I have put up a revised revised draft on the first chapter of my thesis on the Bahai Commonwealth. The topic is not crystal-ball gazing about the future, but rather an examination of the intentions of the community’s founders, by looking at their writings and actions. Chapter 1 is on the House of Worship. I am hoping for feedback please: what is wrong, what is missing, what is redundant? It is a Word (doc) document for downloading here
Posted in Community, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, Theology | Tagged: ecclesiology, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, بهایی, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 11 Comments »
Blessed is the spot …
Posted by Sen on August 23, 2018
“Blessed is the spot” is one of the most widely used devotional works from Baha’u’llah, in both the original Arabic and in translation. It is used as a prayer and as a hymn. It has often been set to music and recorded. It reads, in English:
Blessed is the spot, and the house, and the place, and the city, and the heart, and the mountain, and the refuge, and the cave, and the valley, and the land, and the sea, and the island, and the meadow where mention of God hath been made, and His praise glorified.
This extract was translated by Shoghi Effendi in The Advent of Divine Justice, as part of a compilation of scriptural verses from diverse sources, encouraging teaching activities. He quoted the Arabic text in his Naw Ruz message in Persian, in BE 100 / 1943.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Aqdas and Law, Community, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar | Tagged: Baha'u'llah, ecclessiology, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, scripture, بهایی, بهاءالله, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 6 Comments »
Bahai courts – a short guide
Posted by Sen on August 10, 2018
This posting will look at the institutions of Bahai courts, the House of Justice, the International Bahai Council and the International Tribunal as they are described primarily in the writings of Abdu’l-Baha and Shoghi Effendi. I will assume that readers know what the Universal House of Justice is, and how the National Houses of Justice, known as National Spiritual Assemblies, are elected and function. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Aqdas and Law, Church and State, Community, History | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai, Bahai courts, family law, House of Justice, International Bahai Council, International Tribunal, law of personal status, Shoghi Effendi, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی, عبدالبهاء | 1 Comment »
Instrumental music in the House of Worship
Posted by Sen on June 21, 2018
Hymns, music and singing in worship are mentioned often in the Bahai writings. Many examples are brought together in the Compilation on Music. Abdu’l-Baha writes to one Bahai:
Music is regarded as a praiseworthy branch of learning … Chant (or sing) the verses of God in the great congregations and grand oratories, in the most wondrous accents, and raise such a melody in the Mashriqu’l-Adhkar that the Concourse on High will resonate.
Posted in Community, Devotions, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Arts, Bahai House of Worship, House of Worship, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, Music, pilgrim's notes, Shoghi Effendi, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی, عبدالبهاء | 24 Comments »
Why were the saints [called] saints?
Posted by Sen on September 10, 2017
There’s a quote doing the rounds, attributed to Abdu’l-Baha, that starts:
“Someone asked ‘Abdu’l-Bahá: “Why were the saints called saints?” He replied: “Because they were cheerful when it was difficult to be cheerful, patient when it was difficult to be patient, and because they pushed on when they wanted to stand still, …”
Posted in Bahai Writings, Community, source criticism | Tagged: pilgrim's notes, بهایی, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 2 Comments »
Abdu’l-Baha’s Tablet of Meetings as Mashriqu’l-Adhkars
Posted by Sen on August 7, 2017
The Tablet below has been available in English only in a partial translation. It makes some interesting points about the centrality of the Mashriqu’l-Adhkar in Abdu’l-Baha’s thinking, and is historically interesting for its restriction of meetings, presumably those in Iran, to nine persons, so as to avoid inciting opposition.
The Mashriqu’l-Adhkar or Bahai House of Worship, has a prominent place in Baha’u’llah’s ‘Most Great Book’, the Kitab-e Aqdas, which commands the people of the world to build houses of worship “throughout the lands.” It has a central place in Abdu’l-Baha’s writings, particularly his correspondence, where it is called “the greatest divine institute,” and it is named by Shoghi Effendi as one of the “two primary agencies” of the Bahai Faith and “the crowning institution in every Bahai community.” Baha’u’llah has given a rather direct indication of the kind of community he envisioned by naming his house of worship the Mashriqu’l-Adhkar,
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Bahai Writings, Community, Devotions, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, Translations | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai, Bahai Faith, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, Sen McGlinn, مشرق الاذکار, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 4 Comments »
The consensus of the faithful in Bahai theology
Posted by Sen on March 28, 2017
“…the apparently democratic idea of the consensus of the faithful always ends by according authority to a category of scholars …”
In 1992, a letter on behalf of the Universal House of Justice stated that:
Some people [in the Bahai community] have put forward the thesis that in place of the Guardian’s function of authoritative interpretation, a check on the Universal House of Justice should be set up, either in the form of the general opinion of the mass of the believers, or in the form of a body of learned Baha’is – preferably those with academic qualifications. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Theology | Tagged: Bahai Faith, bahai theology, Sen McGlinn, بهایی, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 37 Comments »
Let’s talk ….
Posted by Sen on August 6, 2015
… about Mehrangiz Kar and the service of women, about open and courteous discussions, and more
This posting begins with the following letter from the National Spiritual Assembly of the Bahais of the United States, dated July 31, 2015, in response to Bahai involvement in an embarrassing internet fracas. The letter itself explains the situation further: Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Bahai Faith, elections, Mehrangiz Kar, pilgrim's notes, Sen McGlinn, مهرانگیز کار, women, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 31 Comments »
Two letters of Abdu’l-Baha in praise of the Mashriqu’l-Adhkar
Posted by Sen on July 21, 2015
The Mashriqu’l-Adhkar is a House of Worship or Temple, built not just for Bahais but for all the people in a community to use. The name means ‘the place where God is remembered,’ and remembrance in this context has the combined senses of awareness and praise. ‘Where God is remembered’ is not just in a building: it is also in the heart, and in a devotional meeting, and in a community. For more information on the Mashriqu’l-Ahkar, see ‘The Mashriqu’l-Adhkar Handbook,’ in the ‘compilations’ section of this blog. (Opens as a PDF file) further compilation this blog. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Devotions, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, Translations | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai Faith, Cambodia, places of worship, Sen McGlinn, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 2 Comments »
“… a body of learned Bahais”
Posted by Sen on July 15, 2015
On a facebook group, one Bahai wrote:
“Obviously the House of Justice needs someone w/ an appropriate background to explain the Writings to them.” This was in the context of letters that showed the Universal House of Justice’s understanding of Bahai teachings evolving over time. I will give more details below.
I am sure the suggestion was well meant, but I think it is heading in the wrong direction entirely. However first I will have to explain why the suggestion could be made. The ‘problem’ for the Bahais, is that it is clear from doctrine and practical observation that the Universal House of Justice, the head of the Bahai community, does not always understand the Bahai scriptures correctly. If there was a guarantee that it would always be correct, the Guardianship would have been unnecessary. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Theology | Tagged: Bahai Faith, Bahai Studies, bahai theology, Lesser Peace, pilgrim's notes, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, Udo Schaefer, Universal House of Justice, y2k, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 38 Comments »
Changes in the Bahai calendar: what, how and especially, why?
Posted by Sen on September 22, 2014
[December 26: the dates of feast days and holy days for the coming years have been added to the bottom of the blog. [Skip to the table]]
On July 10, 2014, the Universal House of Justice announced three decisions regarding the Badi` (Bahai) calendar that has been used, in two slightly different forms, by Bahais in Islamic lands and in the rest of the world. The changes take effect from the next Bahai New Year, from sunset on March 20, 2015. The full text of the letter from the Universal House of Justice is available in the documents archive of this blog. The changes modify the pattern of the Bahai year somewhat, harmonise practices for Bahais in the East and West and – in my view most significantly – they underline that the Bahai Faith is an independent religion and an independent religious community with its own identity. What are the changes about, how will they effect us in our local communities, and why are they introduced now? And the otherwise unspoken question, “Is this more than an unnecessary and irritating inconvenience, haven’t we (and haven’t they), got better things to do?”
The answers to these questions in brief are, that there are reasons in scripture and in what I will call cultural ‘politics’ why these changes should be made now, and that the new dates for feasts and holy days will not be difficult to use in practice, or very different from those we are used to. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Baha'i calendar, Bahai Faith, Calendar, Sen McGlinn, بهائی, بهائیت, تقویم بهائی, سن مک گلین | 22 Comments »
“Without reference to particular individuals”
Posted by Sen on April 23, 2013
From the moment Pope Benedict announced his retirement, the names of possible successors were being discussed, along with ideas about the right kind of Pope to lead the Church in the years to come. A South American? An African? … It all makes for good press. Bahai elections, even the forthcoming election of the Universal House of Justice, are not so newsworthy.
The Bahai community has no clergy, in the sense of qualified religious experts who lead a religious community. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Bahai, Bahai Administrative Order, Bahai Faith, elections, Sen McGlinn, Universal House of Justice, بهایی, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 28 Comments »
“Matters of State” or “administrative matters”: the scope of the House of Justice
Posted by Sen on November 5, 2011
[Updated May 2012, December 2016, July 2021]
In 2008, I posted an entry about the translation of the Eighth Ishraq, which is the eighth section of one of Baha’u’llah’s shorter works, the Ishraqat or Splendours. The posting explained why I thought that the 1978 translation authorized by the Universal House of Justice was incorrect where it says “All matters of State (‘umuur-e siyaasiyyah) should be referred to the House of Justice.” The earlier translation by Ali Kuli Khan, “Administrative affairs are all in charge of the House of Justice, and devotional acts must be observed according as they are revealed in the Book” was, I thought, more accurate, and more consistent with other works by Abdu’l-Baha and Baha’u’llah. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Bahai Writings, Church and State, Community, Translations | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Administrative matters, Affairs of the people, Ali Kuli Khan, amur-e mellat, amuur-e mellat, Aqdas, ‘amuur-e siyaasiyyah, Baha'u'llah, Bahai, Bahai Faith, bahai theology, Bisharat, Church and State, Community, House of Justice, Iqan, ishraqat, lawh-e dunya, matters of state, Organic unity, politics, Religion, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, Tehran, The Art of Governance, theocracy, theocratic, Translation, بـهاءالله, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 36 Comments »
‘You can never organize the Bahai Cause’
Posted by Sen on December 16, 2010
I’m not a historian: I’m interested mainly in the timeless task of understanding the Bahai teachings, leaving history to those able, and crystal-ball gazing to those interested. But those who don’t know their history, will repeat mistakes in understanding quite needlessly, so sometimes we need to look back at the history of an idea in the Bahai community, especially where it is a mistaken idea that keeps resurfacing. In this case I am looking at some words attributed to Abdu’l-Baha, Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, source criticism, Theology | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Administrative Order, Agnes Parsons, Annie Boylan, Baha’i Faith in America, Bahai Administration, Bahai lore, bahai theology, Helen Goodall, House of Justice, Isabel Fraser, Louis Gregory, Mariam Haney, Mason Remey, Mirza Ahmad Sohrab, Mountfort Mills, North Shore Review, Oliver Scharbrodt, organisation, Percy Woodcock, Peter Smith, pilgrim's notes, Remey, Robert Stockman, Ruth White, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, Sohrab, Sohrab's diary, Spiritual Assembly, Thornton Chase, Y.S. Tsao, سن مک گلین | 12 Comments »
Shapur’s poem
Posted by Sen on June 17, 2010
Contributed by Ahang Rabbani
Shapur (Hushang) Markazi was a Baha’i from Gilan. For a number of years he served with great distinction on the National Spiritual Assembly of the Baha’is of Iran and later as an Auxiliary Board member. In the early years of the Islamic Revolution (1979), he was arrested and imprisoned in the notorious Evin Prison in Tehran. After much torture, he was executed on September 23, 1984, because of his religious convictions. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: anti-Bahaism, Bahai Faith, Bahais in Iran, Iran, literature, poetry, religious persecution, Sen McGlinn, torture, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 2 Comments »
Too tender for the House?
Posted by Sen on May 23, 2010
The Universal House of Justice is an elected body that serves as the head of the world-wide Bahai community. It is empowered to decide when Bahai laws are applicable for Bahais, to provide the necessary framework so that they can be applied, and to make laws and rulings for situations that are not covered in Bahai scripture. So it has a very important role in Bahai community life. Unlike all the other Bahai institutions and roles and positions in community life, membership of the Universal House of Justice is, at least for now, reserved for men. I will return to that ‘for now’ briefly, at the end of this posting. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Church and State, Community, source criticism | Tagged: Church and State, feminism, House of Justice, International Tribunal, Organic unity, Sen McGlinn, women's rights, World Order of Baha'u'llah, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 44 Comments »
Muhammad Ali revived? (2)
Posted by Sen on April 17, 2010
In a comment on my earlier posting on the latest attempt to revive the ‘Unitarian’ variant of the Bahai Faith, as expounded by Abdu’l-Baha’s younger brother Muhammad Ali, one reader wrote:
> I dont feel I have anything to fear from Muhammed Ali or most members
> of the UBA. They simply have a different narrative based upon certain
> historical facts, progressive ideas .. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, History | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Baha'u'llah, Bahai Faith, kitab-i-aqdas, Sen McGlinn, Will and Testament, بـهاءالله, بهائی, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 26 Comments »
Pluralist society
Posted by Sen on April 4, 2010
This is in response to ‘Pluralist Society is an Unethical Rabble’ on another Bahai blog on WordPress, Owen’s Meanderings. Owen says he is
“increasingly reminded of that famous biblical story about Sodom and Gommorroh,” … the men and women who sit in government seats must take their share of the blame for the inequities within a nation. However increasingly I have realized that the person living in my street is likely to be twice a corrupt as a politician. … There seems to be very few people who have self-regulating ethical decision-making process. .. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Church and State, Community, Ethics and Morality, Individualism, Political science | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai Faith, multiculturalism, pluralism, pluralist society, political theology, postmodernism, Sen McGlinn, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 21 Comments »
Abdu’l-Baha’s last tablet to America
Posted by Sen on February 21, 2010
Abdu’l-Baha’s “last tablet to America” was published in Star of the West and Bahai World Faith. It is a long tablet, and of some historical and doctrinal importance. It deals primarily with the importance of the Bahais shunning “any person in whom they perceive the emanation of hatred for the glorious Beauty of Abha” or “violators” — Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Aqdas and Law, Bahai Writings, Community, Defence of the Faith | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai, Bahai Faith, covenant-breaker, covenant-breaking, Sen McGlinn, Star of the West, بهائی, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 1 Comment »
The Pilgrims’ Hostel and the Mashriq’l-Adhkar
Posted by Sen on February 7, 2010
I think the meaning is wider than simply “pilgrim’s hostel.” Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar | Tagged: Bahai House of Worship, hostels, Mashriqu’l-Adhkar, pilgrimmage, pilgrims, Sen McGlinn, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | Leave a Comment »
Days of marriage
Posted by Sen on December 20, 2009
A friend asked about the ‘days of marriage’ which Abdu’l-Baha referred to in a letter to Alwyn Baker in late 1920. That led me to two letters from Abdu’l-Baha, one of them translated by Shoghi Effendi and available only in an edited form, the other not available in English in Ocean and the other search engines, and containing some remarks on philosophy, evolution and the eternity of creation. And, in the end, I also found out about the ‘days of marriage.’ Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Bahai Writings, Community, History | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Alwyn Baker, Bahai community, Chicago reading room, eternity of creation, evolution, philosophy, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, Star of the West, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی, عبدالبهاء | Leave a Comment »
The mystery of sacrifice
Posted by Sen on October 16, 2009
One of the friends said:
Long ago I picked up a supposed quote from the Bab, “The mystery of sacrifice is there is no sacrifice.” Now I can’t find a source. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, source criticism | Tagged: Bahai Faith, Bahai lore, Louise Waite, Mystery of sacrifice, Seals & Crofts, Sen McGlinn, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 3 Comments »
Instant, exact and complete?
Posted by Sen on October 12, 2009
In a discussion group, one of the participants recalled that Shoghi Effendi had said that the requirement for appointment as a Hand of the Cause was “instant, exact and complete obedience.” It’s a familiar phrase in Bahai discourse, but is it from the words of Shoghi Effendi? Is it about the Hands of the Cause?
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, source criticism | Tagged: Bahai Faith, Bahai lore, Bahais, Hands of the Cause, Helene Blavatsky, Obedience, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, theosophists, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | Leave a Comment »
Knowledge: project or process?
Posted by Sen on May 4, 2009
The Bahai Encyclopaedia Project has begun to put up a selection of online articles. As of today, there are 21 articles online, so it is just a small beginning. Two are classified under “teachings and laws,” but one of these is misfiled: it is on the Letters of the Living and belongs in the history category. That leaves one article on the Bahai teachings, the one entitled ‘children.’
Looking down this article, I was surprised to see that even where better sources are easily available, it draws extensively on The Promulgation of Universal Peace, which is not an authentic source. In a footnote to the footnotes the Encyclopaedia editors even list Promulgation of Universal Peace among ‘scripture and other authoritative texts.’ The author and editor are clearly not aware of source-critical issues, which is not a promising start for such a project.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Bahai Writings, Community | Tagged: Bahai Encyclopaedia, Bahai scholarship, Bahai Studies, Howard MacNutt, Joseph Hannen, new paradigm, pilgrim's notes, Promulgation of Universal Peace, Sen McGlinn, source criticism, Star of the West, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | Leave a Comment »
The world’s a stage
Posted by Sen on April 26, 2009
One of the friends said:
… an elderly lady once told me that Shoghi Effendi had said that the earth would “fall off its axis and spin wildly for three days”… well, I’ve searched and searched for anything even close…
Posted in Bahai Writings, Community, source criticism, Translations | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Ahmad Sohrab, Apocalypticism, Bahai Faith, Bahai lore, causes of World War I, militarism, polar shift, Ruth Moffet, Sen McGlinn, Star of the West, survivalism, World War 1, WWI, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 2 Comments »
Foundations for inter-faith sharing
Posted by Sen on April 18, 2009
Bahais have been frequent participants in inter-faith fora, and like all the participants we need to work out what our basic stance is: are we there to protect our interests and have our say; are we counting the other participants as anonymous Bahais and including them into our project; are we there to show what we have to offer that other religions do not have, and so win converts?
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Islam, Theology | Tagged: Bahai Faith, ecumenicism, future of Christianity, interfaith, prayer for Islam, Rodney Stark, Sen McGlinn, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 8 Comments »
It’s Friday: thank God
Posted by Sen on April 11, 2009
[Revised October 2019]
The wikipedia page for the Bahai Calendar state: “Like Islam, Friday is also the day of rest in the Baha’i Faith.”
That’s not true for Islam: Friday is the day on which attendance at the congregational prayers at noon in the mosque is obligatory for those Muslims who are able, but it is not a ‘day of rest’ in Islam. But what about the Bahai Faith? We do not say our obligatory prayers in congregation (although we may say them, each for himself, during the Mashriqu’l-Adhkar service, but that is another story). Do we have a day of rest, as the Wikipedia article says?
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Aqdas and Law, Bahai Writings, Community, Devotions, Translations | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Aqdas, Badi` Calendar, Baha'i calendar, Baha'u'llah, Bahai Faith, bahai theology, Bayan, day of rest, dhikr, Friday prayers, Gerald Keil, Mason Remey, remembrance of God, sabbath, Sen McGlinn, Sunday, The Bab, بـهاءالله, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 11 Comments »
Stark choices
Posted by Sen on March 8, 2009
In a discussion on this blog, I referred briefly to Rodney Stark’s work on the dynamics of religious growth. Stark is primarily a sociologist, whose contribution to church history is to employ the statistical and analytic methods used in sociology. His book, The Rise of Christianity (1996, Princeton University Press) deals roughly speaking with the first three centuries of Christianity, and the first century of Mormonism, and offers a lot of food for thought for the Bahais.
Stark begins by estimating that there were 1000 Christians in the Roman Empire in the year 40. He notes that in the middle of the third century, Christians were by their own account few in number (p.5), but by the year 300 there were about 5 to 7.5 million Christians: so numerous that a few years later Constantine found it expedient to embrace the church. This has led the church in its own histories, and some scholars, to suppose that there was a mass conversion event in the late third century. But constant growth of 40% per decade, or 3.42% per year, is enough to explain these results: no mass conversion event is required. This is the same growth picture that Stark had found in his previous work on the Mormon church, which has grown hugely in 100 years without mass conversions, and it is supported by the archaeological evidence of church building sizes.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Bahai, Bahai Faith, Benton Johnson, conservative theology, Constantine, devotional meetings, entry by troops, Hoge, Lesser Peace, liberal theology, Luidens, mass conversion, Moonies, Mormons, Rodney Stark, Ruhi, Sen McGlinn, The Rise of Christianity, triumphalism, Vanishing Boundaries, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 7 Comments »
Entry by troops (time to be announced)
Posted by Sen on February 17, 2009
It has been my experience that Bahais often become discouraged as a result of having unrealistic expectations of what is called entry by troops (EBT) and large scale conversion. I would like to look again at what the Bahai scriptures say about this, and at how Shoghi Effendi conceived the historical process of growth. The little that the scriptures say suggests to me that its importance has been over-rated, and that the time-frame of entry by troops, its nature, and how the Bahais can bring it about have all been misunderstood. From my reading of the world and of the scriptures, I suggest that we should not now be greatly preoccupied with entry by troops or large scale conversion: a concern with the needs of the age we live in, and the needs of our Bahai communities today, will indicate healthier, locally-specific priorities which – ironically – will be more conducive to actual ‘growth’ in every sense. We will start by briefly looking back over the last two generations.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Ethics and Morality | Tagged: Bahai Faith, bahai theology, entry by troops, Lesser Peace, mass conversion, Matthew 16:3, millenialism, personal transformation, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, y2k, year 2000, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 11 Comments »
Elections in Baha’u’llah’s World Order
Posted by Sen on January 30, 2009
One of the friends asked three questions:
1. After the World Order of Baha’u’llah is established and the World’s legislative & executive branches of government are arms or derivatory institutions of the Universal House of Justice (which appears to be the case from my readings) will non-Baha’is have the opportunity to vote for the National Assemblies that elect the House of Justice? Alternatively, can/will the Universal House of Justice be elected in some other way?
2. Will the World Legislature and/or Executive be elected or appointed by the Universal House of Justice? Alternatively, is the Universal House of Justice to become the World Executive? If elected, will only Baha’is have the right to vote?
Posted in Church and State, Community, Political science | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, democracy, elections, International Tribunal, Organic unity, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, the Central Organization for a Durable Peace, World Legislature, World Order, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | Leave a Comment »
House of Justice, House of Worship
Posted by Sen on January 21, 2009
Now concerning nature, it is but the essential properties and the necessary relations inherent in the realities of things. And though these infinite realities are diverse in their character yet they are in the utmost harmony and closely connected together. As one’s vision is broadened and the matter observed carefully, it will be made certain that every reality is but an essential requisite of other realities. Thus to connect and harmonize these diverse and infinite realities an all-unifying Power is necessary, that every part of existent being may in perfect order discharge its own function.
(Abdu’l-Baha, Tablet to August Forel, pages 20-21)
In a letter dated 7 April 1999 the Universal House of Justice warns among other things of an “attempt to suggest that the Mashriqu’l-Adhkar should evolve into a seat of quasidoctrinal authority, parallel to and essentially independent of the Local House of Justice.” Although I am not aware that this idea has ever been put forward in the English-speaking Bahai world, the letter may be taken as evidence that it has or may emerge somewhere. So it seems a good idea to consider the relationship between the Mashriqu’l-Adhkar or House of Worship and the Houses of Justice (i.e., the Bahai administrative institutions, which at the local and national level are now known as Spiritual Assemblies). To understand the institutional relations at the core of the organic Bahai community, we will also have to include the guardianship.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Devotions, Mashriqu'l-Adhkar, Theology | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Administrative Order, August Forel, Bahai, Bahai community, doctrine, Guardianship, Haziratu’l-Quds, House of Justice, House of Worship, Mashriqu’l-Adhkar, Organic unity, quasidoctrinal, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, twoness, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی, عبدالبهاء | 2 Comments »
Century of light
Posted by Sen on January 15, 2009
In Century’s end, I showed that Bahais of my generation widely expected universal peace to arrive in the twentieth century. Some of the texts on which this belief was based did not refer to the twentieth century; others did refer to the twentieth century or dates in the 20th century, but were pilgrims’ notes. There may be more, but I have found five such unauthentic sources:
– The Maxwell’s pilgrim’s notes, anticipating the Lesser Peace by 1953.
– Esselmont’s pilgrim’s notes, in the first edition of Baha’u’llah and the New Era, anticipating universal peace by 1957. As Dan Jensen has pointed out, the 1950 edition changed the date to 1963, but it is still just a pilgrim’s note, and universal peace was also not achieved in 1963.
– Sarah Kenny’s Haifa notes anticipating the Lesser Peace in the 20th century.
– A report in the Montreal Star on September 11, 1912, printed in Abdu’l-Baha in Canada p. 35, saying that peace would be universal in the 20th century.
– A talk reported in The Promulgation of Universal Peace page 126, and in Star of the West 3.8.14, calling the twentieth century the century of international peace.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Bahai Writings, Community, source criticism, Theology | Tagged: 7 candles, Abdu'l-Baha, Alexander Whyte, Baha'u'llah, Bahai, Bahai Faith, bahai theology, century, century of light, election, Esselmont, failed prophecy, Isaiah 11:9, Lesser Peace, pilgrim's notes, qarn, Sarah Kenny, Sen McGlinn, Seven Candles of Unity, Shoghi Effendi, Some Answered Questions, The Promised Day is Come, twentieth century, unity of nations, Universal House of Justice, World Order of Baha'u'llah, `asr, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی, عبدالبهاء | 16 Comments »
Century’s end – my two cents
Posted by Sen on January 12, 2009
When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things. 1 Corinthians 13:11
The word ‘century’ appears unproblematic: a period of a hundred years, which in common usage begins with the year 00 (although sticklers will insist that the century begins in the year 01, so that the 21st century began on 1 January 2001). But in reading the Bahai texts, things are not so simple. In this post I want to look at the peculiar significance Bahais have mistakenly attached to the 20th century and what can be learned from the whole affair; in the next posting I will look at what the Bahai writings really say about the ‘century’ (not the 20th century).
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, source criticism, Theology | Tagged: 1 Corinthians 13:11, 20th century, 7 candles of unity, Adib Taherzadeh, Bahai Faith, Bahai lore, bahai theology, golden calf, Kheirella, Lesser Peace, millennium, Paris Talks, pilgrim's notes, Promulgation of Universal Peace, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, The World Order of Baha'u'llah, twentieth century, Universal House of Justice, world unity, y2k, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی, عبدالبهاء | 38 Comments »
He cannot override …
Posted by Sen on December 30, 2008
In Shoghi Effendi’s 1934 letter ‘The Dispensation of Baha’u’llah,’ there’s a well-known paragraph in which he says that “the Guardian of the Faith has been made the Interpreter of the Word and that the Universal House of Justice has been invested with the function of legislating …”. I want to look at the paragraph after that, which deals with the fact that the Guardian is a member of the House of Justice; so that while the spheres of the two institutions are distinct, their memberships overlap. How would that work, with the Guardian or his representative in the room, while the House of Justice was making its decisions?
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Theology | Tagged: Bahai, bahai theology, Guardian, House of Justice, infallibility, interpreation and legislation, literature review, Mark 2:27, Organic unity, Remeyites, right of self-expression, sabbath, Sen McGlinn, separation of powers, Shoghi Effendi, The Dispensation of Baha’u’llah, twin spheres, `ismat, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 19 Comments »
750 muskets
Posted by Sen on December 25, 2008
[Last revised, April 2019]
Did a regiment of 750 musketmen line up to execute the Bab, in a barracks square in Tabriz, and all miss their target? Early accounts, and those closest to Tabriz, do not say that a whole regiment, or 750 men specifically, constituted the firing squad. Later reports, in the Bahai Writings, do say this. Here’s how Abdu’l-Baha tells the story, in E.G. Browne’s translation):
By one rope the Báb was suspended and by the other rope Aqa Muhammad-‘Ali, both being firmly bound in such wise that the head of that young man was on the Báb’s breast. The surrounding housetops billowed with teeming crowds. A regiment of soldiers ranged itself in three files. The first file fired; then the second file, and then the third file discharged volleys. From the fire of these volleys a mighty smoke was produced. When the smoke cleared away they saw that young man standing and the Báb seated by the side of His amanuensis Aqa Siyyid Husayn in the very cell from the staircase of which they had suspended them. To neither one of them had the slightest injury resulted.
(Abdu’l-Baha, A Traveller’s Narrative, p. 26-7)
Posted in Community, History, source criticism | Tagged: A Traveller's Narrative, Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai Faith, Dawnbreakers, Kazem Beg, miracles, muskets, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, Tabriz, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 27 Comments »
Red Tulips
Posted by Sen on December 20, 2008
I have a lovely story to share, told to me by Brent Poirier and shared with his permission. He heard it around 1980 from Inez Greeven, whose sister was India Haggarty, the subject of our story. India Haggarty was a Bahai living in Paris in 1931. I will let Brent tell the story:
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Bahai, Bahai Faith, Bahai lore, Brent Poirier, creativity, doors of perception, dreams, India Haggarty, Inez Greeven, inspiration in dreams, Sen McGlinn, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 2 Comments »
The Supreme Institution
Posted by Sen on December 16, 2008
Older Bahais, like me, will have noticed a new way of referring to the Universal House of Justice, as “the supreme institution.” I think I first noticed people saying this about 1985. In Anna’s Presentation we find “We have already spoken about the supreme institution, which is the Universal House of Justice…”. Paul Lample, in his Preface to A Wider Horizon, Selected Letters [of the Universal House of Justice] refers to “a continuous flow of guidance that comes from the Supreme Body.”
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Ahmadiyya, Anna’s Presentation, Bahai, Bahai Faith, constitutional monarchy, covenant, doctrinal exaggeration, Guardian, International Teaching Centre, NRMs, Paul Lample, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, The Supreme Body, Universal House of Justice, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 5 Comments »
Reward and Punishment
Posted by Sen on December 5, 2008
Baha’u’llah writes:
Schools must first train the children in the principles of religion, so that the Promise and the Threat recorded in the Books of God may prevent them from the things forbidden and adorn them with the mantle of the commandments; but this in such a measure that it may not injure the children by resulting in ignorant fanaticism and bigotry.
(Tablets of Baha’u’llah, p. 68)
Promise and Threat, or reward and punishment, is one of those basic dynamics that acts out at several levels. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Ethics and Morality | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Baha'u'llah, Bahai, Bahai Faith, religion in schools, reward and punishment, Sen McGlinn, بـهاءالله, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | Leave a Comment »
A modern-day Romeo and Juliet
Posted by Sen on November 30, 2008
… i like this girl and she likes me.. my faith is bahai … she is a very strong christian. and she takes the bible very seriously, and i respect that of her, but in the bible there is a verse that says jesus is the only way to heaven, and in another it says a christian shouldn’t get involved with someone non- christian…
there in lies my problem. and she won’t go out with me until i’ve changed my mind about christ and the bible.. now we did go on a date and it went good, but in her and my art class together i got in an argument over my beliefs with her and half of the class today. let alone this wasn’t bad enough she decided not to date me until i’ve changed…
i will not change my beliefs for her. but is there any way one of you could give me some very convincing verses from the bible, or better yet some strong proof to why bahaism is better..
i need a lot of help with this one, i like her a lot and she likes me, but our strengths in our religious beliefs are getting in the way and we both tend to be stubborn, and i don’t want to see someone as amazing as her just leave me…
Dear Romeo,
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Arguing about religion, Bahai, Bahai Faith, Christianity, John 10:16, Sen McGlinn, Star crossed lovers, twoness, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 2 Comments »
Two by two
Posted by Sen on November 14, 2008
There is a delightful story – which I have reason to think is true, in broad lines at least — about the martyr and Hand of the Cause Mirza `Ali-Muhammad Varqa (Grandfather of the Hand of the Cause of the same name who died in 2007). Mr. Varqa made the pilgrimage to the Holy Land during the lifetime of Baha’u’llah. He found himself with fellow pilgrims in the presence of the Manifestation. He watched as Baha’u’llah spoke to the gathering, and thought to himself, “How fortunate I am! To have recognized the Manifestation of God for this Day, and to be in His very presence!”
Then he thought to himself, “I believe that He is the Manifestation of God. But I want to really believe. What could Baha’u’llah do, that would make me know beyond all doubt that He is the Manifestation of God?”
He thought for a time, and then thought, “I have always wondered about the verse in the Holy Qur’an, where it says that Noah brought the animals into the Ark in pairs. This can’t mean a pair of giraffes and a pair of gnats. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Church and State, Community | Tagged: Baha'u'lah, Bahai, Church and State, communism, disciples in pairs, dualism, fascism, fundamentalism, Hand of the Cause, Mark 6:6-13, nationalism, Noah's ark, ontological dualism, ontological pluralims, Organic unity, postmodernism, Quran 36:36, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, twoness, `Ali-Muhammad Varqa, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 1 Comment »
Pray for good government
Posted by Sen on November 7, 2008
In many Christian churches, and in Sunni Islam in particular, prayers for the ruler or government are a routine part of collective worship. Bahais too are told to pray for their rulers. But we do not seem to be comfortable with it: how often is a prayer for the government part of a Baha’i meeting? Perhaps some background will help.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Church and State, Community, Devotions | Tagged: Abdu'l-Baha, Baha'u'llah, Bahai, Church and State, Majlisi, prayer for government, Religion and Politics, Sen McGlinn, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 1 Comment »
The knower as servant (response to Paul Lample)
Posted by Sen on October 20, 2008
I’ve been reading Paul Lample’s “Learning and the Evolution of the Bahá’í Community.” From page 15, he presents various possible roles for the “learned Bahai” in the Bahai community, saying among other things that learned Baha’i is not an “artist”, and concluding “Perhaps the learned Baha’i is more like the ‘scout’ who helps to guide an expedition on a journey into unexplored territory.” I found it striking that he did not mention the possibility that the learned Bahai could be a servant, someone who uses knowledge to minister to the faithful.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Theology | Tagged: Baha'u'llah, Bahai, Bahai scholarship, bahai theology, Community, creative theology, creativity, evolution, learned Bahai, learning, Paul Lample, postmodern, postmodern theology, scholar, scholar as archaeologist, scholar as artist, scholar as scout, scholar as servant, scholars, scholarship, Sen McGlinn, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | 7 Comments »
What is theology, and what’s it good for ?
Posted by Sen on October 1, 2008
On my web site, I’ve put up my part of two discussion threads about theology, and how the Bahai community can face the fact that some people know more than others, on particular topics, but without replicating the structures of past religions in which greater knowledge often translates into greater authority. Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Church and State, Community, Theology | Tagged: Bahai, bahai theology, Church and State, disenrollment, political theology, postmodern theology, reason and revelation, Sen McGlinn, Theology, unenrollement, بهائیت, سن مک گلین | Leave a Comment »
Do assemblies learn?
Posted by Sen on April 3, 2008
The Spiritual Assemblies that administer affairs in Bahai communities suffer from growing pains: and the members themselves are the nerve that feels it the most. If the problem is disunity, is there a point at which it is better for some members to resign? Or should the assembly be maintained, and meet, come what may – even if the problems in the meeting seep out and undermine the good work and good feeling in the community? Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community | Tagged: Administration, Assemblies, Assembly, Assembly meetings, Atmosphere of secrecy, Bahai, Bahai elections, Community, elections, exchange programme, minutes, openness, Sen McGlinn, Shoghi Effendi, بهائی, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, شوقی افندی | 1 Comment »
The puzzle of the Aqdas: joining a few pieces
Posted by Sen on March 29, 2008
I first wrote this as an email posting on 1 Jan 2008. I’ve reworked it as a blog entry. It concerns one of the things that puzzles Bahais from a Christian or non-religious background: what is ‘religious law’ and how do we treat the Kitab-e Aqdas?
Usually this comes up not as a broad theoretical question, but in terms of particulars. Why do women seem to be disadvantaged in the inheritance law, why are they treated differently in regard to some religious duties, and what is that verse about having no more than two wives?
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Aqdas and Law, Bahai Writings, Community | Tagged: Aqdas, Bahai, bigamy, equality, inheritance, kitab-i-aqdas, religious law, religious pluralism, Sen McGlinn, supercession, two wives, women, بـهاءالله, بهائیت, سن مک گلین, عبدالبهاء | 34 Comments »
Youth: every age its own problem
Posted by Sen on February 20, 2008
As a first experiment in blogging, here’s a letter I wrote to the Bahai Youth Council in 1996. The Council had written a jeremiad about the terrible state of youth, and invited comments. They got them.
To the European Bahá’í Youth Council
I have recently received a copy of your paper “The State of the Bahá’í Youth in Europe,” dated May 1995. That is a long time ago – particularly in the life of a youth – and perhaps this paper no longer reflects the thinking of the Youth Council. I hope so, at any rate, because the approach adopted in the paper does not suggest a way forward for either the Council or the youth themselves.
In addition to the general observation that one cannot expect positive output from negative input, two areas in particular struck me as needing re-vision: the approach to morality and to individualism.
Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Community, Ethics and Morality, Individualism | Tagged: Bahai, Bahai Faith, Community, Generation gap, Individualism, Maturity, Morality, Organic unity, Sen McGlinn, Youth, بهائی, بهائیت | 1 Comment »
Violetta Zein mentions this letter, and the preceding events, at around 1 hour 24 minutes in her excellent youtube video:…